Who would you rather have on the Knicks a prime Nash or a prime Kidd?

[AmareForPresident]

[InGodsHands]

Kidd no doubt. He was better on D and crazy (for guard) on rebounds, just what we need right now. And his playmaking is still top notch even now.

[New New York]

Great Question!!!


Kidd no doubt about it!!!!


Nash is a better shooter and thats about where it ends

Better rebounder,Defender and in my opinion better playmaker, plus Kidd may not be a great shooter, but he seems to hit them right when you need him to!


Kidd running Dantoni's system in Phoenix wouldve for sure landed them in The Finals.

[ducktales17]

Great Question!!!


Kidd no doubt about it!!!!


Nash is a better shooter and thats about where it ends

Better rebounder,Defender and in my opinion better playmaker, plus Kidd may not be a great shooter, but he seems to hit them right when you need him to!


Kidd running Dantoni's system in Phoenix wouldve for sure landed them in The Finals.

You used Dantoni and Finals in the same sentence? I don't get it.

[KingStarbury3]

Prime Starbury >>>

[fender0577]

Kidd, is this a real question?

[GordonGecko]

I'll Nash only because we know he plays well under D'Antoni