Results 1 to 15 of 30

Thread: If u could get 1 player back from the Melo deal who would it be and why?

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Quiet Storm New New York's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    2,431
    Rep Power
    15

    Default If u could get 1 player back from the Melo deal who would it be and why?

    Gallo and Wilson are great but Gallo<<<<<<Melo

    and Wilson was my favorite Knick and while I loved his versatility and being able to use him at the 2, he simply was not a 2.

    Felton was nullified by Billups

    Anthony Randolph wouldve been nice to keep, but still being tagged with that word potential into his 3rd season warrants concern if he will ever "get it"


    With that big gapping whole at the 5 Mozgov would have also been nice to have kept too


    So who would I have desperatly wanted back......Anthony Randolph!!!!!!


    Now this is a hypethetical thread so we need to ignore the logistics of the trade to even contemplate the question....meaning, there are players who had to be included to get this deal done as was the case with AR, no way Curry comes off the books to allow us the freedom to do this if AR is not included.

    But, if we if we were allowed to bring any of those guys back it would be AR for me. I don't see him as an All Star but I do see him eventually becoming one of those guys who gives a good team a nice lift....which is basically what Donnie Walsh and Billups say we need right now to compete.


    Ofcourse the argument is that we need a Center so Mozgov would be the obvious choice....yet we needed a Center for much of the time Mozgov was on the roster and even when he was our starting Center he did not provide much help.

    Joel Prybilla to me would out preform Timofey for us.

    Not to mention I suspect The Knicks have their eyes on Dwight Howard next Summer.


    I also wouldve loved to have seen Corey Brewer play for us....I swear him getting cut was apart of some handshake agreement with Walsh and David Khan because that made absolutley no sense to me.

  2. #2
    Huge Member smokes's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    4,226
    Rep Power
    19

    Default

    Wilson Chandler regardless of whether he is a true 2 guard he puts up better numbers that Fields, is a better defender, more explosive and athletic, could play minutes at the 2 and 3 backing up Melo, even the 4 sometimes to back up Amare. I know we have a hole at the 5 but AR/Mozgov are not hard players to replace.

  3. #3
    Veteran STAT1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    NJ
    Posts
    1,361
    Rep Power
    6

    Default

    Originally Posted by smokes
    Wilson Chandler regardless of whether he is a true 2 guard he puts up better numbers that Fields, is a better defender, more explosive and athletic, could play minutes at the 2 and 3 backing up Melo, even the 4 sometimes to back up Amare. I know we have a hole at the 5 but AR/Mozgov are not hard players to replace.
    I agree with this. Wilson was the most polished & well rounded player that we traded away in that Melo package. Right now for this current roster, having Wilson back would probably benefit the Knicks the most. Ray Felton would be my second choice because I liked the chemistry he had with STAT while we had him, & he ran a good uptempo style of play that Chauncey doesn't really do. AR was unquestionably talented & proved that he deserved a much better chance to show his skills in NY while he was here by what he did in his first few games he started in Minnesota. His basketball instincts may have been a little lacking & he definitely needs more seasoning, but if we were a rebuilding team I would have chosen him over any of the players we traded away without question. Gallo was a nice player but he was way too comfortable with disappearing during games for quarters on end & deferred too much to other guys to a fault.

  4. #4
    Super Moderator RunningJumper's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    3,971
    Rep Power
    14

    Default

    This is pretty tough. What jumps out to me is Gallo for spreading the floor and versatility, but would I care so much about his spreading the floor if it wasn't for Mike D'Antoni hyping up his shooting? Sure, he can shoot, but there was a long stretch where Chandler was the better shooter. Also, Gallo wasn't/didn't get himself involved enough and didn't attack the basket enough even though he had the ability too.

    Chandler, before the trade rumors he had an impressive and consistent season. He brought offense and defense. Actually, I just remembered, a few times when I thought "put Chandler on him" to a guy who needed to be stopped, he did it. I might go with Chandler because of that between the two.

    Anthony Randolph? I think he gets way too much hype. Not saying he doesn't have potential, but do people not remember his terrible plays when he did play? I don't agree with D'Antoni on a lot of things, but I wouldn't be surprised if he deserved to be benched. Still, I wonder what he could have done if he stayed here.

    I felt Mozgov needed a lot more playing time because he showed like he could become a good player on both sides of the floor. He had some catching the ball problems, but it didn't LOOK Jeffries bad, and maybe it wasn't. He wasn't great at English. For all I know that could have caused a big communication problem on the floor and it wasn't even that he wasn't good at catching the ball.

    Finally, I get to Felton. He was a warrior. Offense, defense, he gave it his all. What a lot of us forgot is that he was playing so many minutes. He was a lot better than Duhon and still got the same effect. We needed a back-up PG bad. Forget how he played in Denver, career wise, he's been good, a starter. Billups doesn't negate him. The only other PG who was good enough was Anthony Carter, and I don't know if he could play that much, and D'Antoni did not play him enough. Felton is not the ideal PG for two superstar scorers, but, he is good. Let's not worry about if he'd be happy coming off the bench or not, plus he might have started with Billups.

    Ughhhhhhhh, this is a tough choice. I'll give an answer now and I'll think about it and read other posts and maybe I'll change my mind. So........

    Anthony Randolph. I'm influenced a lot by the hype on this one, but he did show versatility, and maybe he could have been a nice hustle player to back up Turiaf.

    Then again.....Mozgov was doing a good job of that and showed to be better....OK! Mozgov it is.

  5. #5
    Veteran
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    2,789
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    It's a tough one. Wilson Chandler was a great player. Gallinari had worlds of potential and draws tons of fouls. Anthony Randolph proved himself to be worth playing time in Minnesota. The answer isn't Mozgov.

    I guess if I had to pick one it'd be Gallo cause I just liked him more than Chandler, although going by our team's needs Chandler as SG/6th man could be really helpful

  6. #6
    Member keyser soze's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    bay area, california
    Posts
    391
    Rep Power
    5

    Default

    Chandler. He was the most versatile player on our team and would be a perfect 6th man on our team. The problem was that being able to pay him was never a realistic possibility.

  7. #7
    Veteran p0nder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    1,322
    Rep Power
    10

    Default

    Looking at our team right now I can see why they were hesitant to include Mozgov in on the deal. Strictly from a needs perspective i would say Mozgov. and then probably Chandler for his ability to play the 2-3-4 and defend anyone, when he wanted to.

    Gallo would be backing up Melo as he is not a starting 2 guard nor a PF. I actually preferred Felton's play to billups last season, but I don't think the deal gets done without us getting billups. AR, well AR had potential, but he wasn't a starting 5 on any team and he'd be backing up Amar'e. I'd keep him as a trade asset but I don't think he would ever make a good fit on the team with the big 3 of billups-melo-amar'e.

    So as our team stands now, I am forced to say Mozgov, only because I think he'd be better then Kwame brown...

  8. #8
    Veteran petescud's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Florida
    Posts
    1,783
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Gallo or Chandler .... either one

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •