I think that you have to consider this:
Has Amare ever been this bad in his entire career ?
Has Melo ever been this bad in his entire career?
The answer to these tow questions is no. Amare and Melo are fantastically talented, veteran NBA superstars, regular all-stars and before this season lots of other NBA teams would give their right arms to have.
So, given that, why are these two players playing so badly?
IT IS THE COMPLETE LACK OF ANY KIND OF STRATEGY !!! A COMPLETE LACK OF ANY COHERENT COACHING !!
These two players that last season we were incredibly excited about having have not suddenly become bad players. Players who can`t score, can`t perform. They have slumped because WE HAVE THE WORST COACH IN THE NBA
Of course other players are an issue but I am using `Melo and Stat. to showcase the arguement. Both these players are great players and great players do not become mediocre overnight. I have no doubt that both players can co-exist, no doubt at all if only we had a coach who actually ran some plays.
Amare Stoudemire is one of the most devestating scorers in the paint. One of the greatest proponents of the pick and roll. What kind of moron coach runs no pick and roll plays when you have that kind of a player?
`Melo is a great post up player. Not just scoring form that position but drawing double teams in so as to play some inside-out game. When was the last time you saw `Melo in the post.
The arguement that the problem is that we haven`t had time to gel is now a completely redundant one, for two reasons.
1. Every team in the NBA had the same. The lockout, the short pre-season, no training camp. therefore, if everyone has had the same then one team can`t use it as an excuse.
2. If it is indeed the case that we are playing so badly because we haven`t had time to gel then things would be gradually improving. With every game that passes we should see little improvements, defensively, offensively, chemistry, etc. As the games come things should gradually get better and we should be seeing the green shoots of recovery as the minutes of the games tick by. That is not happening, if anything, we are actually getting worse.
The reason that D`Antoni is terrible and must go are far too many for me to list, we all know them. He must go and go now before our season is a complete waste. Right now I can`t think of a single team in the NBA that we look like beating.
Our stars have not become bad players, certainly not as bad as they are playing right now. They have no coaching, no motivation. Can you imagine what it would be like as a player of any sporting team if you are losing night in, night out and the coach just tells you to keep doing what you are doing? All D`Antoni does is clap his hands and say "Lets go . . . Lets go" What use is that?
My fear is that Baron Davis will return and we will improve and that will actually mask the complete idiocy and incompetence of no D`Antoni. My fear is that we will have this moron of a coach all season long and come the end of the season we will still be seeing this idiot sitting in his chair, arms crossed doing nothing whilst we continue to brick threes and Amare continues to drive to the basket like a fat woman in a cake shop whose just been told that every cake is free.
Sack the coach, bring in someone who realises that we have, potentially, a completely dominant front court and let`s see the Knicks play some real basketball.
This thread is a good read. Kudos, particularly to Crazy8s, Scipio, Nuckles and Red. I am with Crazy8s but Scipio makes some good points. It is not just the coach.
If we still had Chauncey Billups things would be totally different as he is a leader on and off the court we need.
Thanks for such positive responses guys. There are two main reasons for my above post.
1. I can`t believe that any Knicks fan is still sticking up for D`Antoni. I can only deduce that they don`t actually watch the Knicks.
2. I`m so sick and bloody tired of people saying that Stat. and `Melo are bad players, lazy, selfish, they don`t care etc. etc. And even more annoyed by people who keep saying let`s trade them. They are both NBA superstars. Knicks fans seem to have forgotten that last season Stat. got 30 or more pints in how many games in a row? And that Knicks fans were chanting MVP whenever he got to the free throw line. They are great players and will be again once we have a real basketball coach and not the stuffed manequin idiot pretend coach that we have now. Why do people keep talking about trading them? At the start of the season our front court was being described as the best in the league. I believ that it still is but it just needs to play basketball and not Damphoni`s stupid braindead shot on sight crap. Run the pick and roll and watch Stat begin the destruction of the opponents paint again. Get the ball to `Melo in motion and watch him wreak havoc.
If denver blows us out tonight I can see that being the icing on Dantonios cake.
However I do see the team stepping up tonight as if there was ever a pride game since the trade this is it......Tonight our superstars should be pure superstars,,,,
Reporter: What was your read on Melo's game tonight, a night where we expected more from him, he shot 2 for 12 in 3 quarters....wha- can you get a feel for what's wrong with him?
D'Antoni: I think players are aaaaahhhhhhh a product of the team and........I don't like to look at stats in that manor.
Ladies and gentlemen, we what the ****?
I still don't understand how it's OK for Melo to be 2 for 12 as long as the team is up 8. That's not how accountability works. Is it not ok when we're trailing by 8? Then how come the same shots go up, regardless of the game situation?
What are you saying to yourself as you process this information?
Last edited by nuckles2k2; Jan 21, 2012 at 23:41.
Chris Sheridan - Don't think Knicks will fire M.D'Antoni after that one. If he loses the next one in Charlotte, adios, IMHO. (FYI: J.Dolan was not at game.)
[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]
Hopefully Dolan was watching on TV and saw D'Antoni bench a hot Walker, not play starters in OT and still get killed by the corner 3 like always.