Would you trade Carmelo?

[ScottishKnick]

Fact-Carmelo Anthony has only been passed the first round of the playoffs once, in his NBA career.

Fact-Carmelo Anthony is a playoff choke artist. I'm not even going to go into his archive of playoff series where he shot 36% and got swept in the first round.

Fact-Carmelo Anthony is playing worse than he did in his rookie season.

Fact-Carmelo Anthony is out of shape and will not help this team win games unless he loses weight and reduces his field goal attempts from 18 to 12 per game.

Fact-Antoni sucks as a coach.

Fact-The Knicks can get a lot of value for Carmelo Anthony, because he's a perennial All Star and leads the Knicks in scoring.

Trade JELLO, get some Royal Jelly.

from what i have seen, i agree with everything you write apart from this.

[NicksKnicks]

Trade Melo for Durant, Westbrook and Harden.

Fair deal no?

[NYCLakerfan]

If this team had Doc Rivers, Thibbs, Popovich, or Phil Jackson I bet they'd be atleast number 3 in the East.

[iSaYughh]

If this team had Doc Rivers, Thibbs, Popovich, or Phil Jackson I bet they'd be atleast number 3 in the East.

Lol. Doc Rivers.

[2012]

Trade Melo

[czoneny]

Melo for Josh Smith.

[k260]

Trade stat for a PF that can play both OFF and DEF.

[CalBunny]

I would trade both Stats and Melo behide what's in door #3.

[NYallDay]

Instead of trading Melo, I would untrade for Melo

[Lercher]

Instead of trading Melo, I would untrade for Melo

+1 (Fields screaming: AND ONE!)