Theres not really much more I can add to this thread, you fellas did all did a great job in here.
As for Josh Smith...If it was Amare and Novak for Smith and another player to make the deal work, Id go for it. I love the way Stats been playing, specifically on offense and doing a solid job on the boards, but i still question how long he can stay healthy for. I feel like if you can trade him for a good player, you almost have to go for it. He has 2 years left on his deal after this season.
Im not always the biggest fan of Josh Smith's shot selection and decision making, but hes a good rebounder and a good defender. He runs the floor well and finishes as good as anyone in the game. He wouldnt have to take as many shots in our offense, he could get the majority of his points just by running the floor, cutting to the rim, pick n roll, and offensive putbacks. Our supporting cast is probably more well suited for Smiths game then the Hawks is. On the low Josh Smith is a good team player and does look for his teammates.