He hasn't been amazing since coming back from injury (it'll take some time to be in 100% form), but he has been solid for the most part, and we know how can be when he is on.
I'm not saying I think he should be. Melo is a beast, but so is Amar'e when he's at his best.
Amar'e being the first option also means less iso for our first option (a lot of pick'n'roll). Not calling Melo a ballhog, the ball movement and general hasn't been good.
The bad thing about Amar'e's offense is him turning it over. The great thing about his offense when he's on is how fierce he is.
I don't have anything bad to say about Melo's offense.
What do you think?