I question whether or not you'd be this excited if Rose & Marshall didnt put on a show last night VS the Knicks. The trade is really nothing new, most of us (or at least me) have known about the Knicks talking to the Raps for Rose & Marshall right after VC was traded to the Nets, maybe even for a short period before that.
so in regards to your question of whether or not we like it, im still on defense about the whole thing, I like Kurt, and we'd be losing our best defensive presence in the post.
ALso Penny could be useful in the offseason for a bigger name as well as Tim Thomas.
So if Isiah does this move it could be costly if it doesnt work out, I think its a gamble, a huge gamble, i'd rather Isiah sit tight and try and get Webber, I can see Web and Steph running a great show and some great Pick & Rolls.