Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 110

Thread: Steph marbury..what ranking does he deserve on top PG list

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Posts
    14
    Rep Power
    0

    Default Steph marbury..what ranking does he deserve on top PG list

    This is my ranking of top 10 point guards..post yours and say if u agree with me

    1. steve nash
    2. jason kidd
    3. deron williams
    4. tony parker.
    5. chauncey billups
    6. Baron davis
    7. stephon marbury
    8. chris paul
    9. kurt hinrich
    10. gilbert arenas (#10 ONLY because i consider him as a sg and not a true point..62..50..60 point games..doesnt sound like a true pg to me..

  2. #2
    12th man
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Far far away from the orgy that consist of clyde, 8's, rady, smokes and rono
    Posts
    11,260
    Rep Power
    0

    Default

    The most productive PG's are

    1. Kidd(All around)
    2. Nash(Most valuable)
    3. Arenas(Best scoring)

    These two guys are the future of the PG position in the NBA, they're both at the same level. Paul is underrated. Hornets were banged up, but like I said before, injuries are part of the game
    4. Paul
    5. Williams

    These two guys are some of the most productive/talented offensive PG's you can find in the NBA, both has similar styles, both strong PG's that can pass and score.
    6. Marbury
    7. Davis

    These are winning PG's who had their sucess in the playoffs.
    8. Parker(playing with Duncan helps, Parker is still a great PG)
    9. Billups

    He's overrated a big, solid defender.
    10. Hinrich

  3. #3
    Veteran GetRealistic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    1,370
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    My rankings.


    Nash

    Deron Williams -basically because of his great playoff run and Kidd getting slightly older

    Kidd

    Tony Parker -Duncan helps but since he got that midrange game he's been top notch)

    Agent 0 - not a true PG but can't knock a guy who can drop 50

    Chris Paul

    Billups- Been to the finals twice and was a finals MVP

    Baron Davis- Amazing when healthy

    Andre Miller- I know i'm going to catch hell for putting him over Marbury but Miller is the definition of the word point guard. Just look at how he made Phila halfway decent after the Iverson trade.

    Marbury- As much as i hate him he has amazing talent levels

    Raymond Felton- He'll be good

  4. #4
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    NY 'til I Die
    Posts
    321
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Originally Posted by metrocard
    The most productive PG's are

    1. Kidd(All around)
    2. Nash(Most valuable)
    3. Arenas(Best scoring)

    These two guys are the future of the PG position in the NBA, they're both at the same level. Paul is underrated. Hornets were banged up, but like I said before, injuries are part of the game
    4. Paul
    5. Williams

    These two guys are some of the most productive/talented offensive PG's you can find in the NBA, both has similar styles, both strong PG's that can pass and score.
    6. Marbury
    7. Davis

    These are winning PG's who had their sucess in the playoffs.
    8. Parker(playing with Duncan helps, Parker is still a great PG)
    9. Billups

    He's overrated a big, solid defender.
    10. Hinrich
    i agree 100%

  5. #5
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Posts
    10
    Rep Power
    0

    Default

    YALLL are crazy,.. I understand parker has some rings but ****k!! so does John sally( as a matter of fact hes got a good 5 or 6 rings i believe) doesnt mean he was the greatest pf. Parker is talented but the top signifigant pg's are Jason Kidd,steve nash, because they obviously make or break a squad.. U take parker , iverson or arenas or any of those listed bums above off there team that team will more than likely have the same odds of achieving anything they planned on with they players.The prob with marbury is he is not surrounded by matured talent..this year i hope is a diff story,!

  6. #6
    Veteran nyk_nyk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Posts
    3,529
    Rep Power
    15

    Default

    Originally Posted by infamouz585
    YALLL are crazy,.. I understand parker has some rings but ****k!! so does John sally( as a matter of fact hes got a good 5 or 6 rings i believe) doesnt mean he was the greatest pf. Parker is talented but the top signifigant pg's are Jason Kidd,steve nash, because they obviously make or break a squad.. U take parker , iverson or arenas or any of those listed bums above off there team that team will more than likely have the same odds of achieving anything they planned on with they players.The prob with marbury is he is not surrounded by matured talent..this year i hope is a diff story,!
    Wow, you must be smoking something with that statement. Parker is a BIG part of the success in SA. Sure Duncan is the key piece, but without Parker's quickness and outright scoring ability players like Finley, Bowen and Horry would have a harder time scoring. Having Tony on the court makes it harder to cheat on D because he gets to the paint with ease.

  7. #7
    Superstar jzero29's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Staten Island, New York
    Posts
    643
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    Originally Posted by infamouz585
    YALLL are crazy,.. I understand parker has some rings but ****k!! so does John sally( as a matter of fact hes got a good 5 or 6 rings i believe) doesnt mean he was the greatest pf. Parker is talented but the top signifigant pg's are Jason Kidd,steve nash, because they obviously make or break a squad.. U take parker , iverson or arenas or any of those listed bums above off there team that team will more than likely have the same odds of achieving anything they planned on with they players.The prob with marbury is he is not surrounded by matured talent..this year i hope is a diff story,!
    r u kidding me? Marbury has been out performed by parker all over the place. Sure maybe marbury has gotten him head to head a couple times, but Parker plays exceptionally well. He runs the team, he scores and passes. He's not my number one guy, but he's above marbury. Part of being PG is how you Run the team, If you guys noticed marbury hasn't run this team for several seasons. Part of this teams lack of success is(beside crawford blows) they don't have a PG.

  8. #8
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    245
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    1. Billups ( best all around point can shoot defend rebound and is clutch)
    2. Nash ( his weak D can't be overlooked)
    3. Kidd ( old age can't be overlooked)
    4. Parker ( 3 rings can't be overlooked)
    5. Williams ( Great playoff run can't be overlooked, but let's give him a full season, although I doubt he will disappoint, more than likely one of the top 2 in a season or two)
    6. Kirk Hinrich ( Solid D, Nice shot, great playmaker can't be overlooked, probably top 2 or 3 when Nash and Kidd hang it up)

    7. Baron Davis ( he and Steph are virtually the same player but we have to give the nod to Baron due to his team making the playoffs in the West w/ the same amount or maybe less talent than the Knicks)

    8. Steph ( showed that he can be a decent defender last year, doesn't need to score, but scored when his team needed him most, examples: the game at Dallas and the triple OT victory against Det.)

    9. Chris Paul ( injury last season causes him to drop in my opinion, but is young enough to bounce back and crack the top 5 again)

    10. Delonte West ( yeah I said Delonte West, very good defender, blocked the hell out if Curry twice, good playmaker, and can hit the shot, his team is loaded w/ PG's causing him to be overlooked, but on the right squad, he could shine.)

    Gilbert just plays point, no way he can be considered to be one in my book

    Honerable mention TJ Ford

  9. #9
    Go 1990s New York Knicks! nyKnicks126's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    1,842
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Originally Posted by Isiah's Advocate 33
    1. Billups ( best all around point can shoot defend rebound and is clutch)
    2. Nash ( his weak D can't be overlooked)
    3. Kidd ( old age can't be overlooked)
    4. Parker ( 3 rings can't be overlooked)
    5. Williams ( Great playoff run can't be overlooked, but let's give him a full season, although I doubt he will disappoint, more than likely one of the top 2 in a season or two)
    6. Kirk Hinrich ( Solid D, Nice shot, great playmaker can't be overlooked, probably top 2 or 3 when Nash and Kidd hang it up)

    7. Baron Davis ( he and Steph are virtually the same player but we have to give the nod to Baron due to his team making the playoffs in the West w/ the same amount or maybe less talent than the Knicks)

    8. Steph ( showed that he can be a decent defender last year, doesn't need to score, but scored when his team needed him most, examples: the game at Dallas and the triple OT victory against Det.)

    9. Chris Paul ( injury last season causes him to drop in my opinion, but is young enough to bounce back and crack the top 5 again)

    10. Delonte West ( yeah I said Delonte West, very good defender, blocked the hell out if Curry twice, good playmaker, and can hit the shot, his team is loaded w/ PG's causing him to be overlooked, but on the right squad, he could shine.)

    Gilbert just plays point, no way he can be considered to be one in my book

    Honerable mention TJ Ford
    Billups the best PG in the NBA... Never.

    OH and whats Kidds age got to do with his numbers this season. He is a triple double player, and you rank him below Billups!! .

    1.Steve Nash+
    2.Jason Kidd+
    3.Gilbert Arenas+
    4.Chris Paul+/-
    5.Deron Williams+
    6.Tony Parker+
    7.Chauncey Billups+/-
    8.Stephon Marbury+/-
    9.Kirk Hinrich+
    10.Baron Davis-
    11.Sam Cassell-
    12.Allen Iverson-
    13.Mike Bibby-
    14.Ray Felton+/-
    15.TJ Ford+/-

  10. #10
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    245
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    Originally Posted by nyKnicks126
    Billups the best PG in the NBA... Never.

    OH and whats Kidds age got to do with his numbers this season. He is a triple double player, and you rank him below Billups!! .

    1.Steve Nash+
    2.Jason Kidd+
    3.Gilbert Arenas+
    4.Chris Paul+/-
    5.Deron Williams+
    6.Tony Parker+
    7.Chauncey Billups+/-
    8.Stephon Marbury+/-
    9.Kirk Hinrich+
    10.Baron Davis-
    11.Sam Cassell-
    12.Allen Iverson-
    13.Mike Bibby-
    14.Ray Felton+/-
    15.TJ Ford+/-
    I was in a hurry while making my list so I didn't give it the kind of thought I should've, and left off some of my favorite PG's like Bibby, Andre Miller and Tinsley peep the new list....
    1.Kidd
    2. Billups
    3. Nash
    4. Parker
    5. Williams
    6.Hinrich
    7. Baron Davis
    8. Mike Bibby
    9. Steph
    10.Chris Paul

    Honarable mention Gilbert Arenas( he's really a 2) Andre Miller, Delonte West, Jamal Tinsley, TJ Ford, and Jason Terry.

    What I shouldv'e said instead of Kidd's age was his injuries and that is why I initally had him second to Chauncy, but there probably hasn't been a triple double player like him since Magic, and I think no other player has ever made his teammates better that J. Kidd, I mean what has K-Mart, Kerry Kittles done since, and look how he rejuvenated V. Carter. I think Billups isn't as good a playmaker as Nash, but is far more superior on the Defense end ( think Eddy Curry to Dwight Howard).

  11. #11
    Superstar ShairanXIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    501
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    Originally Posted by metrocard
    The most productive PG's are

    1. Kidd(All around)
    2. Nash(Most valuable)
    3. Arenas(Best scoring)

    These two guys are the future of the PG position in the NBA, they're both at the same level. Paul is underrated. Hornets were banged up, but like I said before, injuries are part of the game
    4. Paul
    5. Williams

    These two guys are some of the most productive/talented offensive PG's you can find in the NBA, both has similar styles, both strong PG's that can pass and score.
    6. Marbury
    7. Davis

    These are winning PG's who had their sucess in the playoffs.
    8. Parker(playing with Duncan helps, Parker is still a great PG)
    9. Billups

    He's overrated a big, solid defender.
    10. Hinrich
    I'd put AI at #4 and switch 6 & 7... but otherwise... I co-sign...

  12. #12
    Member KnicksFan4Realz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Phoenix,AZ
    Posts
    406
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    The fact some of you did not even mention Gary Payton is astonishing...head to head in their primes...GP atleast 3x better than Marbury.

  13. #13
    Superstar ShairanXIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    501
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    Originally Posted by jimkcchief88
    Thank you. Y'all must be smokin' dat goody good to put Marbury anywhere near the top ten PG's in the NBA. At least 16 PG's are better because those teams make the playoffs. Can you Imagine Marbury on Dallas or Phoenix?? Yeah he is buried on the bench and only gets mop up minutes. Marbury had a better season last year than I thought but to put him anywhere near the top ten PG's in the league buy any rank but salary is a joke. Top 10 point guards LEAD their teams into the playoffs instead of riding the pine down the stretch with a towel on the thier head. Look how Baron Davis played in the playoffs hurt and lead his team to an improbable upset. You can't even put Baron and Marbury in the same sentence. I'm a true Knicks fan but damn, Marbury might not even be the best PG on the team, let alone top ten in the league.
    soooo... you rank these guys ahead of Steph:

    (1) T. Parker (SA) (2) Nash (Pho) (3) Terry (Dal) (4) Alston (Hou) (5) Williams (Uta) (6) AI (Den) (7) Smush Parker (LAL) (8) Baron Davis (GS) (9) Chauncey (Det) (10) Nelson (Orl) (11) Larry Hughes (Cle) (12) Antonio Daniels (Was) (13) Ford (Tor) (14) J. Kidd (NJ) (15) Jason Williams (Mia) (16) Hinrick (Chi)

    This also means that guys like Chris Paul and Cassell are worse points than Smush Parker... see how stupid that logic is? Steph might not be the top 3 player he once was... but he's still top 10 (IMO)... remember how bad his numbers were in November and December when Isiah was benching him? Discount those months and steph had a very good year... don't sh*t on steph cuz we haven't made the playoffs in a while...

    Originally Posted by KnicksFan4Realz
    The fact some of you did not even mention Gary Payton is astonishing...head to head in their primes...GP atleast 3x better than Marbury.
    This list is based on last season...

  14. #14
    OG GoKnIcKsDLEE42's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Long Island
    Posts
    1,399
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Originally Posted by dialdayo
    This is my ranking of top 10 point guards..post yours and say if u agree with me

    1. steve nash
    2. jason kidd
    3. deron williams
    4. tony parker.
    5. chauncey billups
    6. Baron davis
    7. stephon marbury
    8. chris paul
    9. kurt hinrich
    10. gilbert arenas (#10 ONLY because i consider him as a sg and not a true point..62..50..60 point games..doesnt sound like a true pg to me..
    As of right now-pretty accurate. Just switch the 3 and 4 spots,and the 6 and 8 spots-you put stephh right where he should be.

  15. #15
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Edmonton, Alberta
    Posts
    455
    Rep Power
    11

    Default

    I think the best PG in the League is Jason Kidd. If Steve Nash could defend, he'd be Jason Kidd. However the NBA never made him an MVP, when clearly in 2001 he was. Deron Williams could potentially be the next Jason Kidd. He makes the game ridiculously easy for his teammates. My rankings:

    1. Jason Kidd
    2. Tony Parker
    3. Steve Nash
    4. Chauncey Billups
    5. Baron Davis
    6. Chris Paul
    7. Stephon Marbury
    8. Andre Miller
    9. Gilbert Arenas
    10. Kirk Hinrich

Similar Threads

  1. Starbury...what a joke!
    By JerseyCityNETSfan15 in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 23
    Last Post: Mar 20, 2006, 08:41
  2. If the Knicks want Brown, get rid of Marbury
    By Cakalusa in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: Jul 29, 2005, 21:04
  3. Knick Concerns
    By mrj18 in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: Jan 04, 2005, 14:51
  4. newspaper article request
    By NY all day BABY in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: Dec 28, 2004, 12:04
  5. Steph May Take Kidd's U.S. Spot
    By frankwilliams in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 45
    Last Post: May 20, 2004, 20:05

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •