I cant believe you made this thread.

At no point will I think the Knicks are better without Marbury. They were starting to play better before he got hurt. Alot of it is because of the month that Robinson and Crawford are having (check my game thread for stats) and because Balkman is finally playin. I think if Marbury had been playin the past 3 games we still wouldve won but all I can do their is speculate.

If we continue to play well, then Marbury comes back and we start to lose then I will say we are a better team without him. I see this not goin away no matter what, people will continue to bring up Marburys name. Some of us will have fair criticism, some of us will have unfair criticism, and others like myslef will continue to defend him.