2005-2006 season: record without Marbury 3-19
2006-2007 season: record without Marbury 2-6
2007-2008 season: record without Marbury 17-41
2007-2008 season: record without Mabury in the starting lineup 17-46
The Knicks will definitely be worse without Marbury. Let's compare the 08-09 projected lineup, if we have Marbury vs if we have Duhon.
PG Marbury SG Crawford SF Gallinari PF Randolph C Curry
PG Duhon SG Crawford SF Gallinari PF Randolph C Curry
Both lineups suck, but the one with Duhon looks even worse. The lineup with Duhon reminds me of a division 3 college team.
Also, the Knicks made the playoffs 4 years ago. I know that's nothing to be proud of, but Duhon can not get the Knicks to the playoffs ever.