Neither, Rudy Gay will win. Nate's hamstring injury will bother him (hamstring injury's linger for ever!) and I can't see Dwight winning it 2 years in a row.
Joe Alexander would have given Rudy Gay a run for his money.
Nate's got more athleticism, but Dwight's got the size advantage. I don't know if Nate will win this time, but I'm pretty sure Dwight Howard won't win. He's just too big for this competition. He was overrated last year, especially during th superman dunk(layup). Dude didn't even dunk it and he got a 50! Nate should just jump from the 3pt line and throw it in the basket. Maybe with the same judges they will give him a 50! LOL!
Nate all the way. He has to come with a sick dunk so that he can shut down all competition. I'm thinking 1080. He's probably the only one that can pull it off because of his size.