Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Mid-Season Report Card

  1. #1
    Veteran JayJ44's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Brooklyn
    Posts
    1,700
    Rep Power
    8

    Default Mid-Season Report Card

    Record: 17-24 (.415 winning percentage); 2GB of eight playoff spot (Milwaukee, which already owns the tiebreaker)
    Last season's record after 41 games: 13-28 (.317 pct); four game improvement.
    Projected finish: 34-48 (would be most wins since 39-43 record in 2003-04)
    President: Donnie Walsh
    Grade: B -- Cleared $27M in cap space for 2010 with a pair of trades on Nov. 21, which sandbagged what was an impressive start to the season but made a bold statement to the rest of the NBA that the Knicks were going to be major players in the free agency sweepstakes. But has yet to replace Cuttino Mobley and continues to pay Stephon Marbury not to play instead of negotiating a buyout. The decision to draft Danilo Gallinari had been a negative until recently. It will be interesting to see if Walsh is active before the Feb. 19 trade deadline. Eddy Curry's contract is the next big one that needs to be moved. Doesn't help that Curry hasn't been healthy enough to play.
    Coach: Mike D'Antoni
    Grade: B+ -- Sure they're seven games under .500, but how many other coaches would be able to squeeze wins out of this make-shift collection of players? D'Antoni loses points for how he handled the Marbury situation after training camp, but also gets credit for making the stand and taking full control of the locker room in the process. His system makes players better, period. Exhibit A is Chris Duhon. Exhibit B is David Lee. And D'Antoni has quickly disproved the notion that he doesn't care about defense. Perhaps with this team he's learned he has to rely on defense in order to survive.
    _________________________
    PG Chris Duhon
    Grade: A+ -- No one on the roster came into this season with more pressure on him, especially with the Marbury situation unresolved when training camp opened. Duhon, a backup in Chicago last season, not only proved he could be a starter in the NBA, but is proving he can be a very reliable floor general and leader. Arguably the most important player on the team right now.
    PF/C David Lee
    Grade: A -- Has turned around a situation where he was expected to be traded by the deadline to now being considered a lock to be re-signed. Continues to surprise Walsh and the coaching staff with his development and abilities on offense. Mid-range jumper went from being a weakness to a strength. Also starting to live up to his blue-collar status by battling centers night-in and night-out while still putting up daily double-doubles. Could he get All-Star consideration? Name some other forwards in the East who are more deserving.
    SF/PF Wilson Chandler
    Grade: B- -- Second-year player has had flashes of brilliance and yet also disappears just as quickly. Streaky shooter who still needs to develop his awareness so to keep the ball moving on offense. Above-average defender who willingly will challenge on the post. Want to see more consistency out of him, as well as more emotion. Still learning, but Isiah Thomas did well with this pick. Plenty to work with.
    PG/SG Nate Robinson
    Grade: C -- True to his personality, his season has been all over the place. Some nights he is a dynamo that brings relentless energy and a lethal shooting touch. But for most of the past three weeks his shot has betrayed him and it caused the rest of his game to go south, as well until a bounce-back game against the Suns in Game 41. A lot is riding on this second half for him as far as his future in New York goes, because the Knicks may decide they need a more traditional backup point guard rather than re-sign him to be an erratic, undersized combo guard. But he can be extremely valuable as the first guard off the bench when his game is right. Has to find his identity and stick with it.
    SF/PF Al Harrington
    Grade: C -- Like Nate, his game has been alarmingly erratic. Harrington is a gunner in the truest sense, which is what makes him so dangerous for both an opponent and his own team. When he's on, Harrington can be that unconscious hot, when everything goes in. But when he's not, he doesn't know how to stop himself from shooting and his penchant for one-on-one play brings any offensive flow to a grinding halt. D'Antoni found the best place for him is off the bench and, to Harrington's credit, he has accepted the role and still provides a great deal of scoring.
    SG/SF Quentin Richardson
    Grade: C -- Clearly not the offensive player he was earlier in his career and his three-point prowess isn't there every night (he was 0 for 5 against the Suns from downtown). His body also doesn't fit the NBA prototype for a 2 or 3 spot player, but Richardson does use his strength to his advantage and is a smart player. He's not the stopper her used to be, either. But Richardson has been an important player for D'Antoni because of his leadership ability and the respect he has in the locker room. You can't underestimate the importance of this element from a coaching standpoint.
    F/C Jared Jeffries
    Grade: C -- Might have finally found a niche as a defensive specialist who, at 6-10, can defend point guards and avoid mismatches when switching on a screen. His work against Rajon Rondo, Chris Paul, Derrick Rose and Steve Nash recently has been effective. Jeffries has spent a great deal of time on his shooting, but opponents still know you can double off him and he won't beat you, so he remains a liability on offense. But at least he has found a role and is having some success with it.
    F/C Tim Thomas
    Grade: C -- Capable of providing an offensive lift off the bench, whether it is with his shooting or his passing and also can be an above-average defender. However, as has been the case throughout his career, not always motivated and focused on playing. D'Antoni knows what he has in Thomas and uses him appropriately. The main thing is he will be an expiring contract next season and with the motivation to earn another contract it could be a good thing for the Knicks.
    PF/C Malik Rose
    Grade: D -- His playing time quickly evaporated and it was tough on the respected veteran, who doesn't have the game or body type needed for D'Antoni's system. But you can bet he keeps himself ready to check in at a moment's notice. His expiring contract might have some value before the trade deadline, but it is more likely the Knicks would prefer to have his money melt off the salary cap rather than add another contract in exchange for his. And if the Knicks are in a playoff push later in the season, his experience and poise will be valuable as an influence on the younger players in the locker room and on the bench.
    SG Anthony Roberson
    Grade: D -- Not his fault the Knicks signed him to a guaranteed contract for this season after just two summer league practices. Roberson has a sweet stroke but what you see in practice rarely translates into the game. His defense is also a trouble spot, especially getting through screens and keeping guards in front of him.
    C Jerome James
    Grade: D -- Say this about big 'Rome: for once he showed up healthy and in relatively decent shape, considering his awful conditioning in his previous three training camps with the Knicks. He had no chance of getting on the court in D'Antoni's system, but James did get a pair of appearances and had some fun with them. His season is over after an Achilles tendon rupture and he's likely done as a Knick.
    C Eddy Curry
    Grade: F -- Showed up barely in shape, then got sick in training camp and never recovered. Knee issues are a direct result of his weight, which is definitely over the 300-pound mark at this point. The Knicks would prefer to move him and Curry would be better off playing in a more traditional system, but until he gets into shape he isn't going anywhere.
    SF/PF Danilo Gallinari
    Grade: INC -- He's only played in five games and two of them (the first two of the season) were hardly a good look at his skills. But in the games he has played since returning to the lineup, Gallo showed more than anything an "it" factor that some players seem to possess, even as precocious rookies. Gallianri plays with confidence and awareness and, even with a goofy gait and heavy feet, looks like he belongs out there. But we'll need to see more before we can give an accurate grade.
    Overall assessment:
    Health is always a critical issue. D'Antoni right now is going with his largest rotation of the season (nine) and seems comfortable with it. If Curry ever does make it back before the deadline you can bet they'll get him on the court as often as possible to showcase his low-post ability. If Lee and Duhon continue to mesmerize defenses with the high PNR and shooters such as Robinson, Richardson, Harrington, Thomas and Gallinari can hit those perimeter shots, the Knicks have a chance to stay in the playoff hunt. But the debate still rages on: what would be more valuable to this franchise? An eighth seed and invitation to be a first-round doormat for Cleveland or Boston? Or the chance at another lottery pick, which you won't have in 2010 and hope you don't have for a long time after that?
    [Only registered and activated users can see links. ]

  2. #2
    Veteran OriginalKnickGrandson's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    N.Y.
    Posts
    1,116
    Rep Power
    9

    Default

    Nice post JayJ44...... a little harsh on some of the guy's, but still a good read

  3. #3
    Veteran Paul1355's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    5,497
    Rep Power
    14

    Default One change

    I agree with most of what you said JayJ but Q Rich has been an embarissment more than not.

    He has his games were he shoots over 50% and scores 25 points and goes on fire....problem is he is so inconsistent with his jock shooting that it has cost us games that we should have won.

    Q RIch's chucking has gotten to teh point of no return, has anyone noticed that if he makes his first shot or first few that he starts chucking like there is no tomorrow? Q Rich would be a more valuable player if he cuts down on his shots and feeds people which he is actually good at. Passing is his un known strength which he never uses because he feels he is an actual "leader"....He is not a leader in any way. He tries to act like aleader then blows a shot or makes stupid play...guys cant follow a guy that is a jock that sucks 80% of the time.

    Watch Q Rich's minutes decrease more and more as Gallinari gets more healthy...Gallo is going to take minutes away from both Chandler and Q Rich eventually. Q Rich provides rebounding...C+ defense..a strong SF presence with his wide and strong frame, and a rythm shooter that is he gets hot can be pretty good. Inconsistency is what makes him a D+ player.

  4. #4
    Veteran JayJ44's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Brooklyn
    Posts
    1,700
    Rep Power
    8

    Default

    Originally Posted by Paul1355
    I agree with most of what you said JayJ but Q Rich has been an embarissment more than not.

    He has his games were he shoots over 50% and scores 25 points and goes on fire....problem is he is so inconsistent with his jock shooting that it has cost us games that we should have won.

    Q RIch's chucking has gotten to teh point of no return, has anyone noticed that if he makes his first shot or first few that he starts chucking like there is no tomorrow? Q Rich would be a more valuable player if he cuts down on his shots and feeds people which he is actually good at. Passing is his un known strength which he never uses because he feels he is an actual "leader"....He is not a leader in any way. He tries to act like aleader then blows a shot or makes stupid play...guys cant follow a guy that is a jock that sucks 80% of the time.

    Watch Q Rich's minutes decrease more and more as Gallinari gets more healthy...Gallo is going to take minutes away from both Chandler and Q Rich eventually. Q Rich provides rebounding...C+ defense..a strong SF presence with his wide and strong frame, and a rythm shooter that is he gets hot can be pretty good. Inconsistency is what makes him a D+ player.
    It was actually Alan Hahn from Newsday who wrote that. But I agree with what you said about Q-Rich. He helps us most when he is posting up smaller guards and passing, he's actually pretty good at that. But he'd rather chuck up bad shots, when he's not a good 3 point shooter anymore. I can't believe this is the same guy who won the 3 point contest a couple years ago.

  5. #5
    Veteran Paul1355's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    5,497
    Rep Power
    14

    Default

    Originally Posted by JayJ44
    It was actually Alan Hahn from Newsday who wrote that. But I agree with what you said about Q-Rich. He helps us most when he is posting up smaller guards and passing, he's actually pretty good at that. But he'd rather chuck up bad shots, when he's not a good 3 point shooter anymore. I can't believe this is the same guy who won the 3 point contest a couple years ago.
    lmao

    Yea i can;t believe that either...his glory year came and passed that one year in Phoenix averaging over 17ppg.

    Thanks for clarifying who actually said these words. Alan Hahn has a pretty good idea just that he probably hasn't watched as much Knicks games as we all have or else Q RIch would get a lower rating.

  6. #6
    The Knicks are Back DaTPRiNCE's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Brooklyn N.Y.........Alexandria,Egypt in the blood
    Posts
    3,862
    Rep Power
    12

    Default

    nice find JayJ, i agree with the grades for the most part, they seem pretty accurate to me..

Similar Threads

  1. Where do we go from here?
    By metrocard in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 23
    Last Post: Nov 25, 2008, 15:41
  2. Looking back on the 2003-04 Knicks season
    By metrocard in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: Jun 28, 2008, 22:10
  3. In Fairness to Last Season
    By Kiyaman in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 50
    Last Post: Sep 27, 2007, 16:11
  4. Trimester Report Card
    By Starks in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: Jan 01, 2006, 16:25
  5. Knicks Report Card
    By kriss childs in forum NY Knicks
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: May 07, 2004, 17:37

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •