I can agree w you about needing Paul more. In the NBA, PG > SF.
Seeing as we already have Gallo, who I like alot, I would definitely rather have CP3. But you and others could prolly already guess that..
Melo is a great player, but as I've said he doesn't make players around him better. Paul raises the level of the players around him. He's a juggernaut and a facilitator for others.