It's not the bodies. It's how we get them, with a more restrictive CBA (no MLE), zero draft picks, and zero assets.
If we get them, great. I'm just not as convinced as all of you that everything will fall together nicely. It's going to take a lot of luck.
Add insult to injury, if had Melo not been greedy and signed in the offseason, we would be contenders next year, even with a restrictive CBA.
And I disagree a little that just any bodies will do. The Lakers have Derek Fischer, Lamar Odom, Ron Artest, etc.
How do we get players of that caliber? Not everyone is going to take the vet minimum. You still need GOOD role players to win a chip. Not just any role players.
I hope I'm wrong. I really do. I'm sorry about my lack of optimism. I'm not going to stick my head in the ground and say everything is great. We still need A LOT MORE to compete for a championship. I will be happy when those pieces are here. Until then, we're only a team with a few more wins and maybe 1 extra round in the playoffs. And we all know that's not what this was about.
I see it differently as well.
Billups has a ring. IS clutch. Hits big shots and gets to the free throw line. Plays solid defense. Felton got eaten alive by Nelson in his lone playoff appearance. Billups has played almost 2 entire season's worth of post season games. For this year's playoff run and next... Billups is the better option for NYK.
Mozgov, accoding to Jim Boeheim, is a throwback center and was one of the legit prospects he watched in the WORLDS last summer. A real big with presence and physical nature. But he is raw. Normally takes 3 years for this kind of project. I do agree that this throwin really hurt. Obviously, this is wahy this was the last piece that needed to be worked out. TOUGH to give up on this kid's future potential to be an enforcer in the paint, and with the lack of size NYK have he even mattered to our present... But let's not forget that RIGHT NOW Shelden Williams is a more complete player. He may not be as good, but he is certainly more polished. BETTER DEFENSIVELY and will also be more important this year and next.
NO DOUBT CARMELO IS BETTER THAN GALLO.
And then there's the Chandler for Brewer swap. I think defensively they both have something to offer, and while WC is the better player right now... Corey still will fit in nicely and replace WC somewhat.
All in all, making a run with Stoudemire this year and next.... Carmelo, Billups, Williams and Brewer as a foursome is much better than Gallo, Felton, Chandler, Mozgov.
AR was never playing as long as D'antoni is here, so that point is mute.
AS for Carmelo wanting his money? Why shouldn't he? He earned it. Is it fair owners can treat players like what just happened to Raymond Felton? Model citizen. Does what he's asked to do. Goes 120%. Signs with new team. MOves family. Then gets tossed out like garbage?
Melo didn't demand NYK make the deal. He just told then he wanted his money and wasn't prepared to wait. Why should he risk his worth b/c Dolan and Walsh want him to? Would you risk 30 million for James Dolan?
This trade also does nothing to hurt NYK come 2012, when they want to sign Deron/Paul/Howard.