Nice blog entry...I agree with the premise, but I'm not sure I'd be okay with your starting 5. I never thought we needed to make a big splash this off-season prior to the Jefferies trade. I agree, I would have liked to rebuild via the draft the way OKC has done.
I think if we could have landed a guy like Luis Scola or Marcus Camby to play C and FINALLY move Lee to be a real PF (I know, Jefferies started at C, but he guarded PGs, leaving the big men for Lee to guard) as well as a PG like Ray Felton (or even if we could have made a trade for just Sergio Rodriguez) while keeping our picks, we would be in a pretty decent situation soon. I've stated over and over (and you've reiterated) that it takes a while to actually rebuild through the draft, but it's very do-able if you just look around the league. It sucks b/c Isiah had us in the shitter for 5 or 6 years, trying to rebuild the WRONG way (by trading for over-paid, past-their-prime "stars"), we had a chance to rebuild the right way.
Problem is, New York fans (not everyone, and certainly not everyone on this board) are generally impatient, unwilling to wait for change to come. They want shit done yesterday. I have a few friends that don't follow basketball all that closely who, before the trade deadline, were counting on LeBron coming to NY and some of whom after the trade deadline that didn't realize Jefferies being traded opened up a chance for 2 max that we didn't have before. In short, most Knicks coverage and "fans" have fallen by the wayside, but after the media pumps up LeBron in 2010, everything else would be a bust and a waste of the last two years. It's funny because you hear a lot of the commentators on the radio say "We've been fed this LeBron stuff for the past 2 years." In my recollection, Donnie never mentioned LeBron specifically, he only mentioned cap flexibility, it's the media that created these lofty expectations.
In any case, at the trade deadline we really had two choices:
1) Stay put, keep our picks, rebuild slowly and get some supporting pieces in with the cap space we had (pissing off many fans who expected LeBron or a big superstar and starting a media shit-storm); or
2) Go for broke and try and get 2 superstars (and, if we get them, attract fans back to the Garden)
Quite frankly, Knicks management does not care about my dollar, they do not care about the dollar of really anyone reading this. My dollar will go to the Knicks, it has been and it always will. The fact that you are on this board reading this means you can support this team in its darkest era, the Knicks brass does not need to KEEP your dollar coming in, it always will. They care about attracting the casual fan, the one that always thought we were definitely getting LeBron, the one that does not follow the team closely, the one that used to spend money until 1999, then started spending it on the Jets, Giants, Yankees, Mets, Rangers, Islanders, Devils or whomever. They care about recouping THAT dollar. To me, it seems like the deal at the deadline with Houston and Sacto were about going for broke, putting all the chips in and going after LeBron because that's what the CASUAL fan expects.
I think the hardcore fans, those of us that have stuck with the team through all the garbage, they knew would be here any way. I personally would have preferred building through the draft like the Thunder did and like the Bulls did. But I see the allure, I see the reason the Knicks front office felt as though they HAD to make the trade, and HAD to make a SERIOUS play for LeBron NOW.
But all in all, a very good and interesting blog post. How would you feel, though, about this team bringing in a couple good centers (Scola and Camby would be my choices) so that Lee can be a true PF, where he really belongs, resigning T-Mac at low cost, trading Wil The Thrill for a draft pick and maybe a scoring-PG that can split minutes with Rodriguez (because, let's admit it, Rodriguez is pretty good, but very limited on offense)?
PG - Rodriguez/?
SG - McGrady
SF - Gallinari
PF - Lee
C - Scola/Camby