Who would you have???
- Thread starter jrdrny
- Start date
knicksin60
Starter
Shawne Williams of course!
Jamal Crawford is a ballhog that can't play defense and would deny Melo of taking the last shot of a game.
Jamal Crawford is a ballhog that can't play defense and would deny Melo of taking the last shot of a game.
AmareForPresident
Starter
Shawne Williams, Crawford isn't worth giving up TD or Fields. Plus I think Shawne is a better fit and we desperately need a backup SF.
StarksOverJordan
Benchwarmer
Both!
Look at this lineup :thumbsup:
C- Chandler
PF- STAT
SF- Melo
SG- Fields
PG- Baron
Crawford
Douglas
Shumpert
S.Williams
Jordan
Bibby
Jeffries
:crossfingers:
Look at this lineup :thumbsup:
C- Chandler
PF- STAT
SF- Melo
SG- Fields
PG- Baron
Crawford
Douglas
Shumpert
S.Williams
Jordan
Bibby
Jeffries
:crossfingers:
Crazy⑧s
Evacuee
Williams - $1.8M - twice his current offer and $3.8M less than Crawford.
I would hate to see us throw $5.6M at Crawford, and realize that Shumpert is a bigger, stronger, more athletic version of him.
If Crawford signed for 1 year, fine. But that would no doubt be at the cost of Williams.
I would hate to see us throw $5.6M at Crawford, and realize that Shumpert is a bigger, stronger, more athletic version of him.
If Crawford signed for 1 year, fine. But that would no doubt be at the cost of Williams.
A*TRIBE*CALLED*QUEST
Rookie
Williams of courseeeee .. i had enough of crawford from the last time he was a knick -__-
SSj4Wingzero
All Star
Williams.
Crawford is a good player but we don't need more scoring from this team. Between Mike Bibby and Carmelo we have enough non-defense playing guys
Crawford is a good player but we don't need more scoring from this team. Between Mike Bibby and Carmelo we have enough non-defense playing guys
RunningJumper
Super Moderator
Would love both. Out of the two, Williams. He seems to be satisfied with turning his life around and not being after big money. Give the guy the money, he wants to be on the Knicks.
I love how people say we don't need more scoring.
Do you remember who our coach is? I don't think you comprehend the fact that we have 2 guys who like to dominate the ball, but we also need other shooters they can pass to.
If Fields has developed a more reliable jumper, fine. But we need someone to backup that SG/SF spot and be able to either create a shot, or make a shot.
You saw Crawford is a ballhog....well yeah, he is.... but I can assure you that he will know his role once he gets to the Knicks. I doubt he'll be trying to show up Amare and Melo, I think he's matured to the point where he will want to contribute in the best way to help the team.
I'd prefer Williams only because of how much he would cost. I am not opposed to Crawford in an way, shape, or form. This is a different team now with a different mentality, and Crawford would have no problem adjusting to that.
Do you remember who our coach is? I don't think you comprehend the fact that we have 2 guys who like to dominate the ball, but we also need other shooters they can pass to.
If Fields has developed a more reliable jumper, fine. But we need someone to backup that SG/SF spot and be able to either create a shot, or make a shot.
You saw Crawford is a ballhog....well yeah, he is.... but I can assure you that he will know his role once he gets to the Knicks. I doubt he'll be trying to show up Amare and Melo, I think he's matured to the point where he will want to contribute in the best way to help the team.
I'd prefer Williams only because of how much he would cost. I am not opposed to Crawford in an way, shape, or form. This is a different team now with a different mentality, and Crawford would have no problem adjusting to that.
NY17KNICKS
★Melo Mafia★
Guys dont worry, unless Crawford pulls off a huge surprise. We are signing Williams tonight or tomorrow.
Will we be able to sign both mo evans and williams? No idea what the market value is on evans but he seems like he would be a good bench player to come in either at Shooting Guard and Small forward..
natethegreat
Rookie
give me jamal for sure