We did not win a championship with Ewing or with camby/spreewell are they frauds !!! Only one team can win each year all we can hope is that we can compete . Tell me who you are going to get (be realistic) that is going to get us 54 wins and a shot at beating the heat.
To me it's a business decision with Melo. Signing Lebron, Harden or Kobe to a 129M max deal when the last year of their deals is when they're younger than 30 is one thing but Melo will be in his mid 30s in his last year. I wouldn't offer him more than a 4 year deal with the last year a player option, if he really wants to stay with the Knicks he'll take it like Dwight took less money to go to Houston. Let's see how this season goes if we do as bad as Schoen of ESPN says then I don't see any compelling reason to resign Melo or Chandler for that matter.
That's the problem who cares about being a NBA scoring champ?? That doesn't win you nothing if you have one guy that over looks the open man and runs around dribbling the ball until the clock runs out and forces up shot after shot.Bottom line Melo has done nothing since he got here but pad his stats.He could care less about playing defense,hustling,ball movement,team ball, and chemistry. Do you want a team with one player that shoots all of the shots and may get you by the first round or do you want a team with all the players on the same page with great chemistry that plays team ball and wants to win like the Ewing teams? I know my pick and that's the Ewing teams/era
GREATEST KNICK EVER!!!!
Im actually surprised at the responses. I see the consensus is that many of you aren't pleased with what Melo has done so far and him leaving, you guys wouldn't mind. Am I reading it right? But you guys basically stated what I have been saying amongst other basketball fans about Melo. He's a talented and gifted scorer. He is definitely one of the best we have seen in the league, but that alone doesn't win. I don't think he's a selfish player but he is a "score first" player and too often than none, doesn't get others involved. His defensive energy and effort is subpar. Guys like Mj, Kobe, LeBron, Wade, CP and KD scan till have a profound affect on their team and the game even if they're aren't scoring as much. They exert just as much effort on the defensive end as well. If he isn't scoring, what else is he doing?
In this league, you need guys who can play both sides of the ball. Look at how Indy has risen in the last few years. George and Hibbert are by no means "elite" scorers but take as much pride on D as they do on offense. Now look at their team. The knicks will be a solid team this year but they aren't even top 3 in the east imo. I think he's staying but it'll be interesting to see nonetheless.
See this is what im talking about .. the Knicks-Team win a game and Dolan's big media headlines are "Melo scored 29 points for the Knicks win".
The Knicks Jason Kidd & Kenyon Martin strong leadership took the Knicks-TEAM on a strong-run to win 16 games out of the Knicks final 18 games of the 2012-13 season (Kenyon Martin only played 18 reg-season games for the Knicks, replacing injured Tyson Chandler.). Those two ex-teammates that took the Nets to the FINALS twice were the number #1 reason the Knicks won the Atlantic division title, and recieve the NBA 2nd worst playoff team in the first-round (The Rondoless Celtics).
The only Postseason team the "Rondoless Celtics" had a chance to beat in a 7 game series in 2012-13 were the 38-44 Bucks.
Last year when the Miami Heat was on the longest winning streak in NBA history, the majority of the Miami Heats headlines were on Chris Anderson (Birdman) joining the team, plus all the post games reports, u had Lebron, Wade, Bosh, and Ray giving the game win to the "Birdman". A big oposite of the ISO-Melo Melo Melo Knicks...
The Knicks 2008-9 roster were a 2nd round postseason team .. without a clueless Isiah Thomas in the pic, or a phony lying Donnie Walsh in the pic, or a celebrity headcoach Dantoni DNP healthy players to TANK the season.
The Knicks 2010-11 roster were a meshin postseason team, before we got involve with the Chaotic Melo-trade, we only needed to trade for a veteran SG, or a veteran combo-guard in the 2012 February trading deadline to replace Landry Fields in the starting lineup.
We did not need to trade 3 of our starters and 2 future first round picks for the Denver Nuggets two feuding-bitter players "Melo & Billups" on who Nuggets team it was.
Billups Leadership lead to a WCF postseason team vs Melo leadership the following season lead to a first round postseason team.
nah u got me wrong .. I like Melo, on any team other than my Knicks.
I liked Marbury, on any team other than my Knicks.
My Knicks are not like the average NBA team, my Knicks will trade a winning Knicks player at the drop of a dime, and hold on to a loser-cancer player for 4 to 6 seasons.
In the 1980-81 season the Knicks starting lineup of "Sugar, R.Wiliams, Toby Knight, and Cartwright" had a 50 win season, the Knicks brass couldnt wait to trade these players. Jordan would not have won any championship from the "Bad Boys" without Bill Cartwright Big-Body laying-out Lambeer, Mahorn, and Rodman in the paint.
Knicks HC Pat Riley grabbed "Starks & Anthony Mason" from the CBA league, and made the two players our SG n SF to go to the FINALS. Once Pat Riley resign the Knicks brass couldnt wait to trade Anthony Mason the next season, for a player Larry Johnson who was feuding hard with Patrick Ewing's Georgetown brother Alonnzo Morning.
u can count the games on one hand how many times Larry Johnson receive playingtime as a Knicks in 4 seasons.
I can't see him leave New York. He will retire as a Knick.
well MELO confimed to shut down last year contract n he will be FA in 14 so ESPN will be serving again FA Drama
interesting what will be with Lebron too.
This would be Melo-Sanity .... I wouldn't pay more then 15 Mil a year for him (esp for a longer term contract) so off he would go
u hit the right number .. $15M per is the MAX amount that Melo's past 4 season performance were worth.
Plus the East got bigger over the offseason, so expect ISO-Melo to play less than 35 games before going under the knife to secure his contract negotiation with Dolan in June/July.