we probably should have kept nene.

LJ4ptplay

Starter
And Camby. 2nd worst trade in Knicks history (Camby + Nene for McDysse).

1st worst trade = Curry
3rd worst trade = Mebury.
 

dave2138

Rotation player
If that 2010 pick turns out to be John Wall..then the Marbury trade becomes the worst trade in franchise history.
 

ANU

Starter
Are you serious?

Nene missed nearly 200 games in the last 5 years....
as opposed to mcdyess, who played and took us to the playoffs till he retired from his glorious knick career, no? this team hasn't had a legit center since the ew.
 

New New York

Quiet Storm
No Layden should have drafted Amare

Ward
Houston (H20 was a beast that year)
Spree
Amare (rookie of the year!)
Camby

If he had done that we would have never had to endure Isiah Thomas.
 

Pedro De Pacas

Benchwarmer
as opposed to mcdyess, who played and took us to the playoffs till he retired from his glorious knick career, no? this team hasn't had a legit center since the ew.

Well...Mcdyess only missed about 40 games in the same time, whereof there have been 20 this season because he was involved in the Iverson-Trade.
Assuming that Nene would still be here, you have to consider Mcdyess having spent the same amount of time as a knick.
So yes, I'd prefer Mcdyess over Nene (at least for the past 5 years).
 

abcd

KnicksonLIN.com
The Knicks should have drafted Brook Lopez. Nene is injury prone, and he is overrated. His stats makes him look better than what he really is. This is the only season where Nene averaged over 7 rebounds and over 1 block. Eddy Curry had a 19.5 point, 7.1 rebound season, and look at him now.
 

knickzrulezH20

Sexy Stud
lol so just because nene has one good season in the past 6-7 years we shuda kept him? its ny bro lol, we blasting curry for missing one yaer, wat u think we wuda done with nene? we wuda blasted his confidence away, hes lucky thts hes a fan fav in dever to they were patient (fans i mean)
 

metrocard

Legend
Nene always been great.

Excellent defender
Passer.
High FG% shooter.

He just never been healthy.

Dude is as talented as Amare.

and would of been the best big man on the Knicks.

Plus we would of kept Camby too.

Lame trade.
 

dre48ny

Rotation player
We can't keep playing the results, "what if, what if". Management has to focus on the present and learn from previous poor choices. We can retool.
 

jzero29

Rotation player
what if spreewell choked vangundy?

What if spreewell choked Jeff Vangundy?

What if Eddy Curry Choked on a cheeseburger?

What if basketball was played with cheesburgers instead of basketballs, would Jerome James have been the best Knick ever?

The answer to these questions we will never know.
 
Last edited:

Dirk

Benchwarmer
this team hasn't had a legit center since the ew.

I think you are forgeting someone here

jeromejames.jpg


jarome 'too legit to quit' james
 

Pedro De Pacas

Benchwarmer
Nene always been great.

Excellent defender
Passer.
High FG% shooter.

He just never been healthy.

Dude is as talented as Amare.

and would of been the best big man on the Knicks.

Plus we would of kept Camby too.

Lame trade.

No question that is was a bad trade, Nene has a lot of talent, but so does McDyess. Health is the issue.
 
Top