I believe NYK brain trust thought DSJ had elite level talent -- most rational observers understood that -- but I think they also thought that chances were very slim DSJ would reach that plateau (b/c of atttitude and drive). They looked at his lack of desire to play defense and his quick finer blaming others when losing arrived....
I'm not saying that's who DSJ is,
Just what I've heard some scouts and execs claim about him.
Ultimately, unless we were privy to all the intel and reports NYK brain trust had, it's hard to even guess what direction we would've gone in.
From the outside looking in.... sure, DSJ was the smarter pick.
I also know, given enough intel that raised warning flags with dSJ and then other reports coming in elevating Frank.... maybe going safer is wiser? Who knows.
At least we weren't Lakers, BOS and ORL.... all 3 passed on fox.