Walsh & Kidd on the Triangle & Free Agency
- Thread starter Red
- Start date
Walsh another.... "Keepin It Realer"
Walsh when translating is saying to Phil...
"I've done your job for decades including in the current city you're in and for the exact same team. I'm a New Yorker born-bred in Manhattan and knows the makeup of this city as much as anyone affiliated with the Knicks."
"Don't think you're gonna get the guys you really want(need) just because you're Phil, you can try but these free agents are gonna do themselves."
"I know this too because we once had approximately the same amount of cap space 5yrs ago and I had 4 guys lined up before I got one of the last big fish left. He wasn't the most desired, nor was he a player who desired us from the start. We were the last resort for each other."
Kidd is saying what you'd expect someone to say, who although now a coach knows what it means to have players come help you win. I don't think anyone feels Melo is a real deterrent. What Melo more than likely isn't is an attraction against other competition.
Walsh when translating is saying to Phil...
"I've done your job for decades including in the current city you're in and for the exact same team. I'm a New Yorker born-bred in Manhattan and knows the makeup of this city as much as anyone affiliated with the Knicks."
"Don't think you're gonna get the guys you really want(need) just because you're Phil, you can try but these free agents are gonna do themselves."
"I know this too because we once had approximately the same amount of cap space 5yrs ago and I had 4 guys lined up before I got one of the last big fish left. He wasn't the most desired, nor was he a player who desired us from the start. We were the last resort for each other."
Kidd is saying what you'd expect someone to say, who although now a coach knows what it means to have players come help you win. I don't think anyone feels Melo is a real deterrent. What Melo more than likely isn't is an attraction against other competition.
Last edited:
Two ex-Knicks that are still in debt to Dolan ..
Yes, both will have some kind optimistic words to say about the rebuilding Knicks.
We will see throughout the offseason .. if Melo give Phil a helping-hand at recruiting FA?
Melo did recruit JR. Smith from China.
We will also see next season .. if ISO-Melo give the Knicks team something other than scoring?
Will Melo play team-defense, rebound, pass, pick/screen/box-out for 30 minutes in every game?
Or will Melo just score & smile for Dolan
Yes, both will have some kind optimistic words to say about the rebuilding Knicks.
We will see throughout the offseason .. if Melo give Phil a helping-hand at recruiting FA?
Melo did recruit JR. Smith from China.
We will also see next season .. if ISO-Melo give the Knicks team something other than scoring?
Will Melo play team-defense, rebound, pass, pick/screen/box-out for 30 minutes in every game?
Or will Melo just score & smile for Dolan
Red
TYPE-A
Walsh & Kidd don't owe us anything. The point is both veterans echoed the same thing I said; the same thing that you doubt. That the triangle is effective and a superstar like Melo and the Knicks for that matter are attractive due to making the game easier for potential FA's.
Not many if any team can offer that at this juncture. Not even the Eastern Conference leader Hawks.
Not many if any team can offer that at this juncture. Not even the Eastern Conference leader Hawks.
Speaking of free agency, bunch of Internet stories surfaced in the last day about how the Knicks getting Greg Monroe is an almost certainty given the parties involved. The most interesting part of the story to me is how it says the Knicks will be happy to give him a max deal. Max deal for a guy who averaged 16 and 10 on a bad team and doesn't play defense well? That is kind of disheartening for me. As has been said a million times on this forum over the last few months, the players we sign don't have to be superstars to make us better, but we have to be getting them at fair market value if we are going to progress at all as a franchise.
Who cares what Donnie Walsh says, he's probably still defending the Amare signing like Dolan still does and I don't think I've heard him say a critical thing about anyone, just isn't done when you might need to do a trade with the Knicks or when Dolan comes around again with 60M in hand to sign another GM like Walsh.
Kidd didn't say anything about the triangle and I wonder what his opinion of it is but he's not running it with the Bucks and neither is Steve Kerr who was PJ's triangle guru with GS. DFish is going to go through the same growing pains with the triangle with the team next year except in spades because they're going to be at least 7 new guys on the team. Face it and listen to the critics, it's an obsolete offense that's harder to implement than spread PnR.
Kidd didn't say anything about the triangle and I wonder what his opinion of it is but he's not running it with the Bucks and neither is Steve Kerr who was PJ's triangle guru with GS. DFish is going to go through the same growing pains with the triangle with the team next year except in spades because they're going to be at least 7 new guys on the team. Face it and listen to the critics, it's an obsolete offense that's harder to implement than spread PnR.
Better get used to overpaying when your owner dishes out 60M to PJ and 25M to DFish. I'd say with the Knicks possibly not even being competitive for the next couple of years FA's are going to want max money more than ever to come here. If PJ signs Monroe to a max deal you have to lose all faith in him as a GM, he's not a bad player but he's not worth max money.
I'd rather see PJ offer a max deal to KLove or Dandre Jordan then Greg Monroe, not saying I want either of those guys on the Knicks but they deserve max deals more than Greg Monroe.
I did say in an old post that I thought the Knicks would go after Greg Monroe and he's gettable because I doubt any other team besides the Knicks is going to offer him a max contract. Sounds like nothing has changed with the Knicks if they give him a max 4 year deal with a player option.
Last edited:
No Kidd is giving politically correct statements because he was once a star player who needed free agents to come play with him and help him win
From what I've been gathering among other social talk sites, most Knick fans do not take kindly to what Walsh had to say and he is a competitor at this point representing a team who wants to remain relevant.
The Hawks have something to offer that we can't...They can sell Free Agents WINNING and being the best in the East. You're getting hella desperate with each post and thread you start
Last edited:
That's a crappy player to target probably a worse fit than Amar'e . $18mil/yr salary to a player of Monroe's ilk is putrid but those are the few options we have.
Draft Towns, sign Monroe to team up with Melo and the Knicks would have a decent front court but Monroe would eat up $18M of your cap space and I think you calculated that the Knicks would have about $26M in cap space this off-season so that would leave the Knicks about $8M to bring in 7 new players if they sign Monroe to a max deal. No wonder PJ said he wasn't happy with the cap space situation.
Which is why he should have sent Calderon packing with a 2018 1st for someone like Thaddeus Young and maybe a future 2nd. We're gonna be somewhere approximately around $25-29mil of cap depending on what he does with some Team Options, Cap Holds, and projected 2-3% increase in cap.
That frontcourt would get eatin alive on the perimeter and get attacked at the time by guards all game long. It would be a sloth of a front court
Last edited:
Red
TYPE-A
I'm desperate but here you are mentioning what you read on some "Social talk sites" as some sort of anecdote.
Please save it. And save your he's being politically correct explanation.
2 people who happen to be veterans said something contrary to a knick-hater poster (you) and now you're emo and mad. I got news for you, no one here took you seriously anyway; we're use to your type. You're actually typical.
Like I said I dub thee Captain Obvious. You're obviously a hater. And the more you type the more you get exposed. Please keep it up.lol
Kidd is a drunk clown, the same guy who said Melo was like Dirk. Then bounced from him leaving $6mil on the table to go work for the competition<--------Melol
I'll take what Billups had to say about Melo over Kidd but you go ahead and run with what Kidd said. Walsh said nothing contrary, although he double talked slightly
A Homeristic Optimist always reaching for the attempt to peg an objective point of view(as hating and trolling), which can be unpopular at times as the framework from which to build a debate. There's nothing more typical than this
Last edited:
Red
TYPE-A
You've been exposed. You bring nothing to this forum but hate and discontent.
Thanks for the attention though. I feel special that you give me, a real fan, attention. Considering how dead this site was I'm wondering what a loser like you was doing here? I mean the true fans basically bounced which coincides with your arrival. Hummm.
What's wrong you couldn't find a Knick-hater site to join?
And here you are... reading my posts, trolling a Knick fan site, posting garbage. Awww I almost feel bad for you. Your emo passion obviously gets the best of you and it's evident in your posts.
I'm curious why you like embarrassing yourself so much? No one here would've known you were a loser if it wasn't for your posts on a dead forum. Are you okay? No friends? Got beat up? What gives?
Well lucky for you and this forum I'll keep pulling your skirt up and exposing you until you learn. Then soon enough my Knicks will be in contention which like the article I posted will further underscore how ridiculous you look.
Thanks again.
Oh I see, now you've come full circle with self. We were all doing fine Tig, htr10, mafra, kiya, chief(not as much lately I believe because the team is so bad) talking about a variety of subject matter
What hit a nerve with you was calling Melody a BUM-SLUG. Just say off limits and we good