I think this is an interesting point. If I remember correctly, a significant aspect of why we gave up what we gave up to get Melo was due to the insistence of also getting Billups so that we'd have a very good, veteran PG running the show. We didn't look great after the trade, but we certainly looked good for the first 3 plus quarters of that game 1 in Boston until Billups got hurt never to return. Then, again if I remember correctly, we re-signed and then used up on our amnesty on him not long afterwards to get Chandler.
For what it's worth, at the time it didn't seem so terrible because we had at least one very good season with Chandler and Billups suffered a major injury the next season, but, the plan seemed to make a lot more sense with Billups being our third 'star'.
Yeah, then the dumping of Chandler and getting Calderon back in return, not so great.
I agree. We need all the first round picks we can get. We have no real reason to believe that we won't be a lottery team every year until we are no longer a lottery team every year.
So you would have been okay if Toronto offered us Kyle Lowry for Calderon and a 2018 1st at the deadline and Phil turned it down again?
What if Memphis offered us Mike Conley for likewise and we turned it down, you would have been cool?
What if Atlanta offered us Jeff Teague for likewise and we turned it down, you would have been cool?
What if Minnesota offered us Rubio and Martin(we were interested in Martin at the deadline) for Affalo/Calderon/1st, you would have been cool?
You see Dolan could have hired you, myself, and Kiya to simply stand pat and protect 1 lonely future pick doing nothing and he wouldn't have had to suffer financially at the rate of $60mil for us to make such a simplistic decision. Where's the innovation, the forward thinking the stockpiling of even low assets as 2nd round picks, where is Phil showing evidence he's fleshing himself out as a GM?
Fans haven't been comfortable with the idea of coming off that pick since we hired Phil, and all this goes to show "IN PHIL AND FISH WE TRUST" was pure mythology.
We're not rebuilding, retooling, going on all in...nothing, watching the wind blow just to see the results management is crap professionalism.